Difference between Asbestos and Non Asbestos Gaskets

, , Leave a comment

Asbestos gaskets

Asbestos gaskets are made of asbestos which is a tough fibrous material which is heat resistant as well as resilient. Asbestos was used for a long time in the production of gaskets as well as other objects such as roof tiles and insulation because of these properties

What is a gasket?

A gasket is a mechanical seal that is used to connect to surfaces in a machine or mechanical device. The purpose of a gasket is to prevent leakage as well as to regulate the transfer of heat between two mating surfaces. Gaskets generally need to be durable and heat resistant.

Difference between asbestos and non-asbestos gaskets

Origin of Asbestos

Asbestos minerals are silicate and include several species in the serpentine and amphibole mineral classes. Varieties of serpentine and amphibole both are made up of needle or fiber-like crystals which are very heat resistant and resilient. These include chrysotile, crocidolite, tremolite, actinolite, and anthophyllite among others.

Asbestos and gasket construction

Asbestos can withstand very high temperatures. This makes it useful in the construction of gaskets which need to withstand high temperatures that can occur inside of machines. Its resistance to chemical attacks also means that the gasket will not weather or lose its effectiveness in certain environments where gaskets made of other materials might.

Potential health risks of asbestos gaskets

Because of the needle-like shape of asbestos, if individual asbestos particles get into the air, they can cause lung irritation if inhaled. Not only will the asbestos fibers irritate and damage human tissue, but it can also lead to cancer. Because of this, asbestos is being phased out of industrial use including its use in the manufacturing of gaskets.

Non-asbestos gaskets

Two common gaskets not made from asbestos are Kevlar gaskets and graphite gaskets. These gaskets are sometimes stronger or more durable than older asbestos gaskets, but they also tend to be more expensive.

Difference between asbestos and non-asbestos gaskets-1

Graphite gaskets

Graphite is the native form of carbon. Graphite is very heat resistant which is why it makes a good gasket and can be used in situations where high temperatures are prevalent. Graphite gaskets tend to be quite expensive.

Kevlar gaskets

Kevlar is a type of nylon. Gaskets made out of Kevlar are very strong, but it is not as heat resistant certain other gaskets which puts it at a disadvantage.

Similarities between asbestos and non-asbestos gaskets

Asbestos gaskets and non-asbestos gaskets both tend to be strong, durable, and heat resistant. This makes them effective, long lasting seals for mechanical devices.

Differences between asbestos and non-asbestos gaskets

Although there are similarities because they are all gaskets, there are also some differences.

  • Asbestos gaskets are relatively cheap and have been in use for a while whereas non-asbestos gaskets are more expensive and newer, usually emerging in response to health concerns over asbestos.
  • Asbestos gaskets have high heat resistance and strength whereas non-asbestos gaskets may or may not have both assets
  • Asbestos gaskets are made of silicate fibers whereas non-asbestos gaskets tend to be organic or carbon-based.

Table to show the differences between Asbestos gaskets vs. non-asbestos gaskets

Asbestos gasket VERSUS Non-Asbestos gasket

Few main points on Asbestos gaskets and non-asbestos gaskets

Asbestos gaskets are mechanical seals between two mechanical surfaces made from asbestos. They tend to be durable and heat resistant because of the fibrous nature of asbestos and the fact that it is silicate in composition. There are however potential health risks because asbestos particles by themselves can get inhaled and their needle-like shape can irritate the lungs and even lead to cancer. Non-asbestos gaskets are made of Kevlar, graphite, and other carbon-based materials. Some of them have high heat resistance such as graphite and others are very strong such as Kevlar, but they don’t always have all the positive properties of asbestos gaskets. They also tend to be more expensive.

Author: Caleb Strom

Caleb Strom has a B.SC. in earth science from the University of California San Diego and is currently a graduate student in geological sciences at California State Polytechnic University Pomona. He has done scientific research in planetary science at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and astrophysics at the Center for Astrophysics and Space Science at UC San Diego.

Facebook Comments
Help us improve. Please rate this article:
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
 

Leave a Reply